For the better part of 10 years, I have had columns printed from time to time in the Tribune. Most of the columns were political in nature and reflected only my personal take on the issues of the day. Strangely enough, one of the early columns, published on February 25, 2016, had to do with my reaction to attending a Donald Trump rally down in South Carolina. At the time, Donald was still a longshot and more of a cartoonish character than a serious contender for the presidency of these United States.
A paragraph from the middle of that column proved to be prescient: “…This guy is good on the stump. Very good…it wasn’t so much what he said as how he said it. He didn’t talk to the crowd, he wooed it…For 50 minutes he held that crowd in the palm of his hand.”
In retrospect, the warning was implicit, “Take this guy seriously, because the folks cheering insanely in that audience take him all too seriously.”
For one reason or another, it has been nearly a calendar year since my words have seen print.
Nevertheless, every so often someone, often a total stranger, will come up to me and ask, “When are you going to write another column?” It’s flattering, even if I have no good answer to explain my silence.
It happened again the other night.
I was attending a memorial service remembering American citizens gunned down like dogs on the streets of Minneapolis, Minnesota.
My God, I thought. Ten years after seeing an affable Donald Trump woo those South Carolina voters, how has it come to this?
Ten years of increasing political bickering. Ten years of intensifying national chaos. Ten years of trying to understand what motivates folks, some of them my friends, to disbelieve what they can see with their own eyes – or find ways to justify what they are seeing.
I know there are those, some with advanced educational degrees, who will defend to the death their allegiance to this president, his drift towards autocracy notwithstanding. Even to defending the chain of events that led to the blood of American citizens soaking the frozen streets of Minneapolis.
I am reminded of the words of Founding Father James Madison, revered as the architect of the Constitution with its representative government and checks and balances, on the death of pure democracies: “…Hence it is that such democracies have ever been spectacles of turbulence and contention; have ever been found incompatible with personal security or the rights of property; and have in general been as short in their lives as they have been violent in their deaths.”
As we stagger towards the 250th anniversary of our national existence, is Madison’s critique about the short duration of such governments and their violent deaths about to be fulfilled here by a government turned over to one man and his faction?
I hear it said that Minneapolis is a “turning point.” That it is the singular event that will cause ordinary citizens, the Joe’s and Kathy’s of the body politic, to send an unmistakable message, by elections or by other means, to a government that is theoretically “of the people, by the people, and for the people” that enough is enough.
Problem is, we have had turning points before — Sandy Hook, Parkland, George Floyd, Uvalde. The fervor of the moment fades, and the comfort of a return to temporary normalcy beckons. The “normalcy” is only temporary because there will be further “turning points” down the road that test the national will until there is no national will left to be tested.
In our current situation, as electoral victors, those in power have the right to pursue their policies. But those they govern have the right to expect those policies and the tactics used to bring them to fruition must square with our laws, our Constitution, and our national sense of right and wrong.
I have my doubts about the longevity of this “turning point”. Whether it will prove to be only temporary or something more substantial remains to be seen.
When the dust settles, I hope to be around and able to find words to mollify Madison’s ghost: “Not yet, my friend, not yet.”
Maybe – just maybe – what Madison helped build will survive. There are no guarantees.